Mastering Peremptory Challenges in Family Law Cases

October 24, 2024


Navigating the complexities of family law can feel overwhelming, especially when it comes to ensuring a fair hearing. One essential tool for parties and attorneys is the ability to challenge the presiding judicial officer using a peremptory challenge under California's Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6. This provision allows for the automatic disqualification of a judge, court commissioner, or referee, ensuring that parties can secure a fair and impartial hearing.

What is a Peremptory Challenge?

A peremptory challenge can be initiated through a timely oral or written motion supported by an affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury. The key is to assert that the judicial officer is prejudiced against a party or attorney, which could hinder the ability to receive a fair hearing. The beauty of this challenge lies in its simplicity: it allows for automatic disqualification without needing to prove specific allegations of bias.

However, remember that only one peremptory challenge is permitted per party in any given action. If a party loses at trial but later succeeds in having that ruling overturned, they may exercise their right to challenge the same judge upon remand.


Timing is Everything

It’s crucial to act swiftly when filing a peremptory challenge. The rules are strict about deadlines:

  • If you know who the judicial officer will be at least 10 days before the hearing, your challenge must be filed at least 5 days prior to the hearing date.
  • If your case has a master calendar, the challenge must be made to the supervising judge when the cause is assigned.
  • For all-purpose assignments, file your motion within 15 days after notice of the assignment or after your appearance.
  • If the court has only one judge, you have 30 days after your appearance to file.

In any case, ensure that you serve notice on all parties no later than 5 days after making your motion.


Navigating Challenges for Cause

While peremptory challenges are common due to their straightforward nature, judicial officers can also be challenged for cause under Code of Civil Procedure section 170.1. This requires specific allegations and proof of bias, such as personal knowledge of disputed facts or financial interests in the case. Unlike a peremptory challenge, which does not require detailed proof, challenges for cause are more demanding and generally less common.

If a judge fails to respond to a challenge under section 170.1 within the allowed time frame, they are deemed to have consented to disqualification, as demonstrated in the case of Hayward v. Superior Court. In this instance, the failure of a temporary judge to disclose a relationship with one party’s attorney led to the voiding of all orders and rulings made during the hearing.


Conclusion

Understanding how to effectively use peremptory challenges is vital for ensuring a fair hearing in family law cases. By being aware of the rules and timelines, you can advocate for your rights more effectively. At M.C. Law, P.C., we’re here to help you navigate the complexities of family law, including the nuances of judicial challenges. Our experienced team is dedicated to protecting your interests throughout the legal process.

Two gold wedding rings on a prenup agreement with text fields for names.
October 23, 2025
Prenuptial vs. Postnuptial Agreements: What Los Angeles Couples Should Know
Judge holding gavel, woman comforting child at table.
September 25, 2025
Minor’s Counsel Attorney in Los Angeles, California: Protecting Your Child’s Best Interests in Court
Adult hand holding a baby's hand, close-up. Soft blue tones.
August 29, 2025
Understanding California Child Support Laws: What Every Parent in Los Angeles Needs to Know
July 31, 2025
How to Safely Leave an Abusive Relationship: Legal and Safety Resources for Los Angeles Victims
A man is holding a newborn baby in his arms.
July 3, 2025
How to Start a Paternity Action in Los Angeles
A silhouette of a family walking at sunset holding hands.
June 5, 2025
When Co-Parenting Gets Complicated: Protecting Your Time with Your Child in Los Angeles
Two wedding rings are sitting on a wooden table.
May 1, 2025
Many couples assume that once they are married, financial and legal concerns are set in stone. However, circumstances change, and a postnuptial agreement can help protect both spouses' interests. Learn what a postnup is, how it differs from a prenup, and whether it might be a good choice for your marriage.
A scale of justice sits on a table in a courtroom
April 3, 2025
Divorce laws vary from state to state, and California has some distinct rules that set it apart. If you're ending a marriage in the Golden State, it's important to be aware of how these laws might affect your case. This blog highlights four unique aspects of California divorce law that could impact your rights, assets, and future.
A black and white photo of a girl holding a man 's hand.
March 6, 2025
When child custody disputes arise, the court may appoint a Minor’s Counsel to advocate for the child’s best interests. But who has the authority to make this appointment? Learn about the key figures involved in appointing a Minor’s Counsel, the criteria for selection, and the role this attorney plays in family law cases.
A man and a woman are standing next to a pile of coins.
February 6, 2025
Circumstances change—often in ways we never anticipated. Whether you’ve lost your job, received a significant promotion, or encountered unexpected health issues, life’s twists and turns can impact your financial stability. For many former spouses, these changes may prompt revisiting alimony arrangements. In California, modifying spousal support isn’t automatically guaranteed; it requires meeting specific legal criteria and following a structured process. At M.C. Law, P.C., in Los Angeles, we’re here to help you understand when and how adjustments to alimony payments may be appropriate, ensuring that both parties maintain a fair and balanced agreement. Recognizing Valid Grounds for Modification Not all changes in circumstances warrant a modification to spousal support. California courts typically consider requests if there has been a “material change” in either party’s financial situation—such as a substantial drop in income, a significant increase in the recipient’s earnings, or new medical expenses affecting a party’s ability to work. The burden of proof rests with the individual seeking the modification, who must demonstrate that the shift in financial standing is both legitimate and enduring. An experienced attorney can help you assess whether your situation meets the threshold for revisiting your alimony terms. Initiating the Legal Process Before you file a request with the court, reviewing your original divorce decree or settlement agreement is important. Some agreements may include specific terms outlining when and how spousal support can be modified. Assuming these options are available, you’ll need to prepare and submit a formal request for a modification to the court. This involves completing the required legal forms, attaching financial documentation, and serving the other party. At M.C. Law, P.C., we guide clients through this complex process, ensuring each step is completed accurately and fully in compliance with state requirements. Gathering Comprehensive Evidence To strengthen your case, you must provide solid evidence that your financial circumstances have changed and justify an adjustment. Relevant documentation may include recent pay stubs, bank statements, tax returns, medical bills, or termination letters from an employer. The more comprehensive and organized your evidence is, the better your chances of a successful modification. Our legal team helps clients compile the strongest possible evidentiary record, saving them time, effort, and potential frustration in a challenging moment. Considering Negotiation, Mediation, or Court Action Not every modification request has to result in a court battle. In some cases, both parties may be willing to negotiate an updated arrangement on their own or through mediation, resulting in a mutually agreeable solution with fewer legal expenses and emotional strain. If these methods fail, the matter may go before a judge who will evaluate the request and render a decision. Regardless of your route, having skilled legal counsel on your side can help you effectively present your case, anticipate counterarguments, and confidently navigate the legal landscape. Adjusting alimony arrangements can feel daunting, but it may be right when your life’s circumstances shift significantly. Understanding the legal grounds, following proper procedures, and presenting compelling evidence can position yourself for the best possible outcome. The team at M.C. Law, P.C. in Los Angeles stands ready to assist you—whether you want to modify your existing support payments or defend against an unwarranted request. With professional guidance, you can ensure that your spousal support reflects the reality of your current situation while maintaining fairness for both parties involved.